NYC 9/11 Public Portal Document
(
preferable to test a piece from a flat, upper horizontal surface which would be more
contaminated.
ASTM microvacuum method Is Inadequate for carpets and other woven fabrics
Some argue that testing carpet and fabrics with the hand-held ASTM microvacuum suction pump
would be a good enough test, since it would get out the easily releasable asbestos. In this
method, carpet and other fabrics are sampled by a hand-held air suction pump. The fabric is
essentially vacuumed by the pump. The asbestos is caught on a filter, and then the filter is sent to
the lab for testing.
However, this ASTM microvacuum sampling pump is only a first-line test for carpet and other
woven fabrics, and is not definitive. The microvacuum pump does not apply any greater suction
than a good vacuum cleaner. High impacts, such as a child running or rolling on the carpet, will
release much more asbestos than any vacuuming process. The EPA ultrasonication method will
extract over 100 times the amount of asbestos from carpet compared to the ASTM microvacuum
method. The ultrasonication method is also an official EPA method specific to carpet, and is
thus preferred.’
NYC APT. BUILDING USES ULTRASONIC CARPET TESTING
The New York Environmental Law and Justice Project’® obtained carpet samples from one NYC
apartment building on Hudson St., near the intersection with Thomas St. The samples were
taken on May 29,2002, over 8 months after the collapse of the WTC. The samples were tested
by EPA’s ultrasonication method. The results are given in Table 1. The building is 9 blocks
north of Ground Zero, and 4 blocks north of Warren St. Warren St. was defined by the New
York City Department of Health as the northernmost point of contamination from WTC fallout.
The building does not have central forced air heating and cooling. Heat is by floorboard hot
water pipes. Air conditioning is by individual window units. There is forced air circulation in
the hallways only. The building is a well maintained with a clean boiler room and basement. As
seen in a later section of this memo, these levels are high, indicating a major asbestos release.
The pattern of the contamination, roof and lower hallway, is indicative of the asbestos source
being the World Trade Center.
-6-
NYC-WTC_000140132
OCR can misread numbers and units. Confirm readings against the page image before using them.