NYC 9/11 Public Portal Document
December 8, 2001 Certified Letter #70012510 0007 4600 2355 page 4 of 6
The objectives of this meeting would be as follows:
(1) verify the expertise and experience of the duct cleaning contractor
(2) assess the merits and possible oversights of the duct cleaning contractor's intended
methods for the cleaning operation and the basic steps employed in their process
(3) clarify what tests have been or ought to be conducted on substances residing in the
duct system--such findings clearly impact upon cleaning methods to be utilized
(4) determine whether further independent supervision is warranted, and if so, specify the
manner of our industrial hygienist's participatory supervision and the subsequent
reporting back to tenants and Related
(5) agree on the testing parameters (substances, locations, media) to be performed at the
end of this cleaning process, in order to certify for all concerned parties that
appropriate decontamination has been achieved
This independent industrial hygienist should play a limited role in monitoring the
cleaning process. This role could be established during the initial meeting. We do not
want to interfere with the cleaning process, only to insure that it is properly conceived
and conducted.
The resultant findings from this meeting (or the failure to hold such a meeting) will be
posted online and available to all 105 Duane residents and workers.
Tenants have held extensive discussions with Joel Kupferman of the New York
Environmental Law Project and are participating in the efforts of his firm and other
organizations to assess the health treats posed by the WTC site. These groups seek to
assess and track the remedial actions (or lack thereof) taken by landlords, business
owners, city, state, and federal agencies in response to this crisis, and to press for revised
legal standards.
The New York Environmental Law Project has put tenants in contact with an industrial
hygienist whom we feel would be an excellent candidate to evaluate the competency of
the duct contractor's methods and plans for cleaning the ventilation system.
Such verification is no doubt in Related's best interests, as well, since it will ensure that
the duct system is in no way damaged by these procedures and an objective presence
could also resolve the question of "sick building" syndrome. Duct cleaners we have
spoken with (via the National Association of Duct Cleaners) suggested that the black
residue emanating from electrical fixtures and duct work in the apartments and common
areas could be evidence of a sick building, incubating potentially toxic mold growth.
We look forward to speaking with one or all of you at your earliest possible convenience.
We know that the duct cleaning is scheduled to begin very shortly, and would therefore
like to follow up with you via phone or a face-to-face meeting as soon as possible. As a
first step, we recommend that you call Pii Ito follow up on this letter. She can
be reached at 718.270.2567, between the hours of 9AM and 5PM.
NYC-WTC 000125869
OCR can misread numbers and units. Confirm readings against the page image before using them.