NYC 9/11 Public Portal Document
j
supported by a combination of' animal,
studies, pharmacological responses of these
CMS disorders, and circumstantial evidence. At
the current time these associations are
somewhat speculative, but there is suffi
cient evidence to justify investigations.
It is now known that the neuropeptides
of neurogenic inflammation reproduce the
pathology of asthma (27), and the role of
neurogenic inflammation has been docu
mented in animal models of asthma (2S).
r' © p p.
Barnes (29) has tecendy reviewed the cur
rent evidence for the role of neurogenic
inflammation in asthma and has suggested
I
p. strategics for reducing neurogenic inflam
mation in this disease. It is increasingly
recognized that respiratory irritants such as
VOCs and environmental tobacco smoke
can exacerbate asthma and rhinitis (30-32).
A number of studies have documented an
it increase in the incidence of asthma in
industrialized countries, over both the long
t- Figure 2. Schematic diagram of neurogenic inflammation triggered by chemical irritants. Chemical irri
term and during the 1980s (35). In addi
I tants IC) bind chemical irritant receptors on sensory nerves to release substance P (P) and other media
tors from nerve endings. Substance P binds receptors on effector cells to trigger inflammation. Neutral
endopeptidase |nep), an enzyme located on the membranes of effector cells, degrades substance P and
tion, studies during the 1980s established
that the American population is exposed to
VOCs in the indoor air (54).
downregulates neurogenic inflammation. It is proposed that chemical sensitivity syndromes are disor The role of neurogenic inflammation
ders of the regulation of neurogenic inflammation. and chemical irritants in these respiratory
Regulatioa of Neurogenic disorders and the upregulation of neuro
substances and results from exposure of genic inflammation by inhalant irritants
Inflammation
trigeminal nerve endings co the irritants. discussed above indicate that there may be
The skin and other mucous membranes Neutral endopeptidase degrades substance a relationship between indoor air pollution
have similar responses to irritant chemi P (i3). NEP is located on the surfaces of with VOCs and the worsening asthma epi
cals. Recent studies in anosmic subjects cells with substance P receptors, i.e., the demic. Pursuit of this relationship should
have separated the common chemical target cells of substance P. Substances that be a research priority. In the past asthma
sense from olfaction (15). The common decrease neutral endopeptidase levels was divided into extrinsic asthma, triggered
chemical sense and olfaction are depicted increase neurogenic inflammation, while by protein aeroallergens, and intrinsic asth
in Figure 1. There is evidence that pro substances chat increase neutral endopepti ma of unknown cause. This distinction
tein receptors on cell membranes are the dase suppress neurogenic inflammation. was made before the role of neurogenic
activation site for chemical irritants. It is Human recombinant NEP suppresses neu inflammation in asthma was appreciated.
thought that sensory nerves act as both rogenic inflammation (18-20). Exogenous It may be that asthma would be better clas
afferent and efferent nerves for neurogenic substances that inhibit NEP include ciga sified as immunogenic or neurogenic
inflammation triggered by chemical irri rette smoke (21), respiratory viruses (Table 1). The distinction between neuro
tants. In the nose, substance P release has (22-25), and the volatile organic chemical genic and immunologic asthma is limited
been verified for exposures to nicotine, toluene diisocyanate (26). to the catalysts because the two types cross
capsaicin, ether, formaldehyde, and ciga over after the release of mediators, in that
rette smoke (16,17). Hence, stimulation Possible Roles of Neurogenic the mediators of neurogenic inflammation
of the chemical irritant receptors leads to Inflammation trigger mast cell degranulation, and mast
neurogenic inflammation. The relation Neurogenic inflammation may play a role cell mediators stimulate peripheral nerves.
ship among chemical irritants, sensory in a variety of disorders, from asthma and This “bidirectional regulatory circuit" has
nerves, substance P, and NEP is summa rhinitis to migraine headache, rheumatoid recendy been reviewed (35).
rized in Figure 2. arthritis, and fibromyalgia. Such a role is This crossover phenomenon docs not
mean that neurogenic inflammation and
immunologic inflammation are clinically
/ Table 1. Immunogenic versus neurogenic asthma
identical in all cases. In the upper airways
f Triggered by
Immunogenic
Protein aeroallergens
Neurogenic
Volatile organic chemicals
and skin, the initial complaint associated
with exposure to chemical irritants is burn
ing or pain, whereas itching is the initial
Interacting with IgE antibody Chemical irritant receptors
Located on Mast cells Sensory nerve C-fibers complaint associated with immune-medi
ated exposures. It may be chat there is
Releasing Histamine, leukotrienes, Neuropeptides; substance P.
prostoglandins, chemotactic naurokinen A, calcitonin
individual variability in the degree co
factors gene-related peptide which crossover is clinically manifested.
Stimulating Sensory nerve C-fibers Mast cell degranulation The two mechanisms might be differenti
ated by testing patients with challenging
Producing Bronchial inflammation Bronchial inflammation
doses of antigens and nonallctgenic chemi
Manifesting as Asthma Asthma cal irritants, while monitoring clinical
Volume 101, Numbers. August 1993 235
CITY_21MC100_006729509
NYC-WTC_000199645
OCR can misread numbers and units. Confirm readings against the page image before using them.