NYC 9/11 Public Portal Document
10/17/2003 09:28 FAX 2024566548 CEQ @002/003
DRAFT 10/17/03
Charge to Expert Panel to Impl ent Targeted Testing Program to Address
Gaps in Indoor Air Program Identified bv EPA Inspector General
The August 21,2003 EPA Inspector General report identifies several gaps in the
indoor residential cleanup program conducted in lower Manhattan. In particular, the EPA
IG report focuses on the following gaps:
• the limited geographic scope of the program;
• the exclusion of commercial space fiom the program;
• the need to assess potential recontamination of cleaned residences in buildings
that have central HVAC systems;
• the need to verify that cleaning has been effective in reducing exposure to all
contaminants of concern;
To address these gaps, the expert panel should design, peer review, and implement a
testing program that includes the following elements:
• identification of the ‘ signature’ of WTC dust using XRF or similar techniques;
■ collection a sufficient number of aggressive air and dust wipe samples to enable
the analysis, within standard levels of statistical confidence, of the extent of
WTC dust contamination in the gq> areas identified above (e.g., Manhattan areas
above Canal Street and Brooklyn, commercial spaces, cleaned and uncleaned
units and HVAC systems in buildings with central HVAC systems, and already
cleaned apartments).
• Testing of collected samples for all contaminants of concern that have been found
in WTC dust, such as asbestos, mercury, lead, dioxin, PCBs, PAH's, fiberglass,
silica, nickel, Ci ium, and chromium.
• Collection and analysis of control samples in the Bronx or other suitable areas
outside Manhattan -
• Use of certified technicians and laboratories that operate in ccIhJl»liance with
standard relevant OSHA standards and regulatory requirements regarding worker
protection. —---------------------- -------------- -
• Adherence to standard ‘chain of custody’ protocols and use of split samples.
Implementation/Timeline
• The panel and the testing must be supported by Administration funding
commitments.
• The testing should be performed independently through cooperative agreement
(e.g., through NIEHS-funded Enviro sntal Sciences Centers who already have
been involved in WTC dust testing and evaluation.)
• Testing protocols, peer review documents, data, and analysis should be publicly
available.
• Testing, analysis and recommendations for follow-up steps, including additional
cleanup if necessary, should be completed within three months.
DRAFT 10/17/03
NYC-WTC_000164364
OCR can misread numbers and units. Confirm readings against the page image before using them.