NYC 9/11 Public Portal Document
Gilsenan, Michael
From: Chapin, Diana [NYCDEP/QUEENS/DIANAC3]
Sent: Friday, March 29, 2002 3:20 PM
To: Gilsenan, Michael; '[email protected]'
Co: Avaltroni, Robert; Sturcken, Charles; Radhakrishnan, Krish; Theodorellys, Penny
Subject: RE: Exterior cleanup
Since you said Jim had spoken to Ron, I spoke to Ron Tramantano directly. He is NOT concerned about the suits. He did
NOT think there is any relationship between the outdoor work and indoor work. He does NOT want to review our scope of
work to check it. He was asked about the standards for vehicle cleaning and indoor air by Jim because Jim had talked to
someone at Corporation Counsel. Ron does not intend to go to any meetings and he is not expressing concern about our
work. I can't speak for Dana at EPA Washington because I do not know her, but if EPA doesn't think what we are doing is
reasonable maybe EPA can do the work instead of us. I'll call Kathy and see if Jim is as far off with regard to them and he
is with State Health.
Alessandra, can you try to stop this from becoming a big issue when it isn't one? The amount of money to sample each
location would probably be very expensive and would lengthen the process a great deal. Also, once we found some
buildings that didn't have to be cleaned up under asbestos regulations, the public would protest that they contain other
substances we don't currently regulate and still try to get us to clean them. This is rooftop cleaning (facades will be
handled at off hours) so we can minimize public alarm since workers can undress before moving to a new location.
By the way, Ron also tells me that although City Health does not want to be involved in any indoor clean up. Miller is
enlarging the lists of contaminants of concern.
—Original Message—
From: Gilsenan, Michael
Sent: Friday, March 29, 2002 2:17 PM
To: Chapin, Diana 001
Cc: Avaltroni, Robert; Sturcken, Charles 001; Radhakrishnan, Krish; Theodorellys, Penny
Subject: Exterior deanup
Jim Miller called me again and informed me that he spoke to EPA and State DOH and that they would like to review
our scope of work regarding the exterior cleanup before our pre-bid conference on April 3. 1 informed Jim that there is
nothing in our scope of work that deviates from our Asbestos rules (Title 15 Chapter 1). I advised Jim that EPA and
State DOH should look at our Asbestos rules so that they can better understand how the work would be conducted.
Jim indicates that EPA and State DOH feel that an argument could be made that by cleaning up outside it somehow
translates to cleaning up inside. Jim is looking to have the cleanup be less obtrusive to the public. I told him that I
don't know how that can be accomplished without all interested parties meeting. Jim indicated that he would ask OEM
to convene a meeting with EPA, State DOL, State DOH, NYC DOH, OSHA and ourselves before April 3.
1
NYC-WTC_000164353
OCR can misread numbers and units. Confirm readings against the page image before using them.