The dangers from asbestos, such as asbestosis, lung cancer and mesothelioma, show up only
after 15 or more years, and usually after long-term exposure.
Called for Help
The one tenant was worried enough that by mid-April she asked Joel Kupferman of the New
York Environmental Law and Justice Project to come to 150 Franklin and collect dust
samples.
Kupferman sent three samples to a laboratory. The lab results showed levels of 1.2%, 1.4%
and 1.8% asbestos. He immediately notified the EPA and the city’s Department of
Environmental Protection, and those agencies analyzed new samples on April 18.
The DEP, using a crude analytical method called polarized light microscopy, detected no
asbestos. But EPA scientists, using a more sophisticated method called transmission
electron microscopy, found even higher levels, from 2% to 5% asbestos.
"We recommended that it be professionally cleaned," said EPA spokesperson Mary Mears.
According to several political and community leaders, 150 Franklin may not be an isolated
case.
"For almost eight months now people in lower Manhattan who who took the word of the EPA
have been living in conditions that are potentially hazardous to their health," said Rep.
Jerrold Nadler (D-Manhattan) through a spokesman yesterday.
Nadler has been demanding for months that EPA test and cleanup the indoor spaces in every
building near Ground Zero.
EPA Administrator Christie Whitman announced a plan recently to assist the city in
cleaning the facades and roofs of buildings downtown, and her aides now say they are
considering what to do about indoor spaces.
2
NYC-WTC_000162116
OCR can misread numbers and units. Confirm readings against the page image before using them.
NYC-WTC_000162116Source: NYC Law Department, mirrored locally
Letter from the NYC Department of Health dated February 8, 2002, summarizing environmental sampling and asbestos testing results at a residential building.