NYC 9/11 Public Portal Document
As shown in Table 15.0, the comparison of these results suggest that no conclusive difference
could be observed.
Overall, the samples collected using the aggressive technique had a slightly higher percentage of
samples below the detection limit (80 percent vs. 69 percent) than the samples collected with the
modified-aggressive technique, while the samples collected using the modified-aggressive
technique had a lower average concentration (0.00045 S/cc) than the samples collected using the
aggressive technique (0.00071 S/cc).
5.9 Filter Overloading
As mentioned above, there were many instances where the filters from the asbestos air samples
were overloaded with particulate material and could not be analyzed, which resulted in invalid
asbestos air results and required additional cleaning events. During the study, the use of an air
filtration device was added to the cleaning method for the third cleaning in an attempt to reduce
the airborne particulate matter as both previous air sampling events resulted in overloaded filters.
This occurred twice. In both cases, there was no overloading of the filters and valid asbestos air
results were received. This prompted an evaluation to determine if there was a noticeable
reduction in overloading filters with particulate matter when an AFD was used during the cleaning
event. The data for all of the units in the building were used to see if there was a difference in the
percentage of units with at least one overloaded filter when an AFD was used.
Table 16.0 presents a comparison of the percentage of units, including residential, common
spaces, and commercial spaces, with asbestos air samples that could not be analyzed due to the
filter being overloaded with particulate matter, and indicates whether or not an AFD was used.
The data suggest that using an AFD during cleaning may offer a slight advantage for reducing the
potential for overloading a filter with particulate matter.
116
NYC-WTC_000145814
OCR can misread numbers and units. Confirm readings against the page image before using them.