NYC 9/11 Public Portal Document
Most usual partloulates are simple products of combustion, and contaln only small
quanittes of toxie chamicale. This may not be true near to the WTC, since there is dear
avidence that dloxins, furans, PCBs, asbestos and several metats ware released during
the collapso and fires. Thus, even if the particulate levels are below the magic number
of 40 ng/m°. It is essential to demonstrate that the particulates do not contain toxic
substances at high concentration. This is done by collecting elther the particulates from
an alr filter of the dust from surfaces, welghtng the sample, and than determining the
relative percentage of the weight that is toxio. This has not be done. There have been
some measurements of taxins in air and on surfaces, but not on the basis of weight.
Furthermore, sorne of the measurements done have been totally flawed. For example,
the sensitivity of the measurement of PCBs in at was 8o low that the smailast value that
could be detected was 4.2 tmes greater than the occupational standard for adutt white
malas, and even that value would not be protective of children.
Other health oxperts recommend no outdoor play at times when the particulate lavels
are high. This is a wise recommendation, but the same recommendation applles to the
Iroside envirorment.
In my ludgerent parents have the right, and Indaad the responsibllty, to demand that
the Indoor ervirormert of PS 89 be pruven to be safe from bath acute and long-teim
heaith hazards before the bullding is reoccupled. There is preseniiy no such evidenos,
and too much doubt to justily re cocupansy at the present time. We must not repaat a
Love Canal ty making dealsions in haste that may adversely affect the heaith of our
children.
A Cmpestr
Prafess
A Number of instantaneous measurements of respirable particulate matter, commonly
called PM2.5, which is the concentration in air of particles finer than 2.5 micrometers in
diameter. Reading are made both inside and outside of PS/IS89, typically between 8 am
and 4 pm.
® Range (minimum to maximum concentration) of respirable particulate measurements
made inside and outside of PS/IS89 on that day.
"Average of all the instantaneous respirable particulate readings made inside and outside
of PS/IS 89 on that day.
D Number of instantaneous measurements that were above the USEPA guideline of 40
ug/m' as a 24-hour average concentration for sensitive groups, including children, the
elderly, and people with heart or lung disease
- Number of instantaneous measurements that were above the USEPA ambient air qualit
standard of 65 ug/m' as a 24-hour average concentration for the general population.
)
€0
NYC-WTC_000144611
OCR can misread numbers and units. Confirm readings against the page image before using them.
NYC-WTC_000144611Source: NYC Law Department, mirrored locally