NYC 9/11 Public Portal Document
BATTERY PARK CITY
K
E.P.A. Says Air Is Safe,
1
But Public Is Doubtful
By SUSAN SAULNY crying, vented their fears to a group
...and ANDREW C. REVKIN of local officials who had come to
calm them and answer questions.
.:---- The Environmental Protection
Agency has tested the air in Lower Many said their distrust comes
rC• cG2 Manhattan more than 1,000 times directly from what they experienced
and witnessed on Sept. 11. “The real
■ ec / □« and has concluded that it d as not
show dangerous levels of contamina issue is: how can two buildings disin
tegrate into thin air — given all the
tion. things in those buildings that were
Of -■ »*-G • V.-' Sampler from the Occupational never meant to disappear into the air
GOC ' G O• x, iJ • Safety anu Health Administration in — and that air be perfectly safe to
dicate no airborne asbestos or other breathe?” asked Mary White, who
contaminants beyond the disaster
cor' Y eo :. site. And Joel A. Miele Sr., the city’s
lives in Battery Park City.
Government officials understand
C- O OO o commissioner of environmental pro the fury as part of “human nature,”
tection, insists that while the air Mr. Miele said, and point out that the
quality can cause nagging discom real respiratory concern should be
fort, “it’s r.ot a health concern.” about something much more mun
But despite those assurances, dane: exhaust. New tests show that
ma"y people who have moved back unfiitered diesel smoke coming from
intt downtown homes and offices are the rescue and construction vehicles
convinced that the air is unsafe, and now .cramming the red zone is the
they say they can produce their own potential new problem.
data about the health risks: sore Nonetheless, residents want inde
throats, tongue lesions, burning eyes pendent air testing and are pushing
and ears and skin rashes. They say for the creation of a new city posi
they are afraid of what could be long tion, a nonpartisan “environmental
term health effects. advocate” who would explain how
The intense fear of contaminated studies are being done and what the
air has spread throughout downtown results mean.
and taken on a life of its own, despite “There’s tremendous distrust of
repeated assurances by the authori the information we’re being given,”
ties, becoming one of the more unex continued Ms. White, who runs an
pected and unmanageable side ef online business from her home. “We
fects of the trade center disaster. feel physically sick when we stay
Over the past three weeks, the there, sore throats, burning eyes,
voices of disbelief have grown louder rashes.”
and angrier. On Wednesday night, at The persistent doubts and fears of
least 1,500 downtown residents residents may actually be deeply
packed a Wall Street hotel lobby, and rooted in human nature and evolu
with much shouting and even some tion, and are apt to continue to out-
r or g.c
M
O(.; oo(ic .I
r n GG c ::
-O('3 c>orc I
- c fl •- • f'* • o « , s
■ oc '.oot?.'- - -J
- G fl v-' G G O o
P I »J3 f.
Martlynn K. Yce/The New York Times
Like many near the World Trade Center site, Nancy Graham, left, and
Janet Heussner, wear surgical masks because they say the air smells.
NYC-WTC_000142090
OCR can misread numbers and units. Confirm readings against the page image before using them.