NYC 9/11 Public Portal Document
J Commisioner Christopher 0. Ward
August 9, 2004
Page 3
I Moreover, while Article 5a of the Contract allows the Commissioner to
amount was required to be
retain from Termon's final payment a sum as security, that
I fixed in the Contract's specifications. No such sum was ever fixed.
Therefore, especially
clear that no money was
in light of the type of work performed under the Contract, it is
I intended to be withheld.
total
It is Termon's understanding that the approved contract billings
$213,800.57 in retainage.
$2,138,005.65. Based on that amount, the DEP is holding
I While a final accounting of the approved contract billings needs to
withhold
be conducted to verify
Termon's retainage.
this amount, there is no basis for the DEP to continue to
3. Cleaning of HVAC Units In Residential Apartments--$913,000.00
Work on
With the Invitation to Bid, the contractors were given a Scope of
the Contract's Scope
which to base their bids. For ease of reference, a separate copy of meeting,
mandatory pre-bid
of Work is annexed hereto as Exhibit B. While there was a contingencies of the
no site inspection was allowed nor was it possible due to the
the information
situation. As a result, the bidders were forced to rely exclusively on
Scope of Work, in
contained in the Scope of Work provided to them. The Contract's
obligated to perform.
fact, omitted a significant amount of work that Termon was
accumulations
Scope of Work A concerned "the cleaning of minimal dust
systems and (c) in the
(light coating)" in (a) common spaces, (b) in the buildings' HVAC
conditioning units in residential
residential spaces. With regard to heating and/or air
clean the
apartments, the Scope of Work only required Termon to remove and work"
"[i]ntake/discharge registers of HVAC systems", to vacuum the "first foot of duct
emphasis added) and to remove and
of the HVAC systems. (Scope of Work A, ¶3.h, ¶3.i). This was the
vacuum "[w]indow and room air conditioners" (Scope of Work A,
systems which was a part of
extent of the cleaning of any of the mechanical appliances or
the Scope of Work provided prior to bid.
window air
Upon commencing work, it was discovered that besides the
HVAC through-
conditioners and HVAC registers, the apartments contained individual
not mentioned in the Scope
wall units. The necessity of cleaning these types of units was performed its
where Termon
of Work for the Contract. Every apartment in Quandrant D
bedroom and at least one
work contained at least two of these HVAC units—one in each
based on the number of
unit in the living room/dining room. Termon's claim is
room area. For
bedrooms in each apartment plus one unit for the living room/dining units. For a
for two HVAC
example, for a one bedroom apartment, Termon is claiming
units.
two bedroom apartment, Termon is claiming for three HVAC
window air
While it may be argued that there is no difference between the
they are, in fact,
conditioning units specified in the Scope of Work and the HVAC units,
work to clean.
significantly different and required significant amounts of additional
NYC-WTC 000135979
OCR can misread numbers and units. Confirm readings against the page image before using them.