FEMA correspondence regarding historic building cleaning treatments, March 2002

NYC 9/11 Public Portal Document

MAR. 15. 2002 1 1 :24AM NO. 792 P. 27

applications as dust or cleaning agents may enter building through openings in facades to

or fabric.

Cleaning Methods: The intent of these standards is to provide general guidelines for the ,,removal of applied paint (or, signage) fr

historic building exteriors that comply with the gm

` Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties. As mentioned above, masonry surfaces should be free of dust prior to implementing a removal program (see Performance Standards for Cleaning Masonry Exteriors).

The following information is explained in greater detail in Preservation Brief Number 38 "Cleaning Graffiti from Historic Masonry" by Martin E. Weaver:

Substrate Identification- Identification of the type of stone'substrate will help determine the type of removal methods. Masonry materials can be categorized as being acid -sensitive, • non-acid sensitive, or alkali-sensitive. The application of inappropriate paint removers or • cleaning agents can damage stone. Acid-sensitive materials include, but are not limited to: limestone, marble, travertine, calcareous sandstones shales; most polished stones; and and

glazed architectural terra cotta and brick. Non-acid sensitive materials include, but are not limited to: slate, granite, unglazed architectural . terra cotta and unglazed brick. Alkali- sensitive materials include, but are not limited to: glazed brick, glazed terra •cotta, some granites Indiana limestone, and many types of sandstone. Strong acids and strong alkalis can damage glazed and polished surfaces.

Removal with Water and Detergent- Water cleaning utilizes the application of a gentle, low pressure, clean water spray. Water alone can sometimes remove paint. If the application of low-pressure water is not successful removing the applied paint, a neutral non-ionic in

detergent may be used in conjunction with a water application. Any detergent being used • should first be tested in a small inconspicuous area prior .to widespread application. The • pressure of water applied to' a masonry surface should be carefully monitored (see "Abrasive Removal"). Inappropriate detergents can cause permanent staining and damage to substrates.

Removal usin.9 Poultices- Poultices are. powdered materials (e.g. clay, paper, cellulose products, fuller's earth) that are mixed with water or a cleaning agent to forna a paste that can be applied to a building surface. Poultices are often the most effective means of removing applied paint (signage) from masonry as they allow the cleaning soluiion to remain in place as long as possible, and draw out the staining material from the masonry. An experienced and qualified professional should apply poultices as improper application can sometimes draw out and redeposit stains on the opposite face of masonry surfaces. , Any cleaning application should be tested in an inconspicuous area or mock-ups prior to widespread on

application. '

Removal utilizing Alkaline Compounds- Alkaline compounds are typically used in poultices in the form of liquids (reagents), applied to markings/stains on non-alkali sensitive masonry. The application of alkaline compounds should be followed by a weak acid wash and a water

21 r

NYC-WTC 000094069